This was so helpful! I was a little confused with the instructions to go to “wp-admin” since I read that as going to my WordPress Admin section, but I stumbled through it. For anyone else reading this, it’s:
Downloads > Settings > Click the Premium Package tab on the left
Then click through the tabs along the top to make sure you’re set up properly.
I will say that the “Premium Package” tab on the Downloads Manager Settings screen made me think it was an advertisement for premium packages rather than the payment gateway setup. Maybe something more clear would help there?
Either way, thanks again for the help on this. So far I am preferring WPDM over Easy Digital Downloads in just about every category! I’ll do a full blog post on it once I make a decision and I’ll definitely include how helpful support was as a free customer.